Block ein- oder ausblenden

Vyberte si jazyk

Český English Français Deutsch Italiano Polski РУССКИЙ

Angled roof ridge.

Q/A about D-Wall, D-Roof, D-Floor/ Ceiling, D-CAM
Odpovědět na témaOdpovědět na téma Vytisknout stránku

Angled roof ridge.

Odeslat Zaslal: 08.08.2017 23:56

Hi.

My brother have a special request that I am not sure I have ever seen in real life. But most probably someone have done it before: To make the roof ridge with an angle. Normally the roof ridge is horizontal. But if one wants an angle on the roof ridge, then how to do that?

I am pretty sure I can do it in roof design, by cutting the roof elements etc. - based on a roof calculation, where the building outlines are angled to the walls.

But is it possible to do it in roof calculation, based on a "normal" building outline, that follows (parallel to) the walls?
_________________
Sincerely Yours. M. Sc. E. Thorvald, Denmark
(Dietrichs version 7.03).

Thorvald
Tera Poster
Tera Poster
 
Příspěvky: 1063
Založen: Aug 16, 2006

Re: Angled roof ridge.

Odeslat Zaslal: 09.08.2017 08:20

Everything is possible in Dietrich's.
If you need an angeled roof on a parallel building, you can work with short (2 cm) angeled lines, which define angle and pitch of the roof.
_________________
Freundlich grüßt
Der_Planer

Der_Planer
Power-Experte
Power-Experte
 
Příspěvky: 10368
Založen: Aug 24, 2004
Bydliště: 51143 Köln

Re: Angled roof ridge.

Odeslat Zaslal: 09.08.2017 09:16

If the eaves are parallel to the rectangular walls and are horizontal but you want to have an angled ridge your roof faces are warped.
You also can do that with Dietrich's, with function 2-05 on roof calculation. But And you have luck because we have this function since your version 7.
_________________
Viele Grüße,
Joachim Neumann (Dietrich's AG)
Software für den Holzbau, Abbund, Holzrahmenbau, Blockbau, Ingenieurholzbau und für die Fertighausindustrie

if (ahnung == 0) { read "Tipps & Tricks"; use SEARCH; use Blog; } else { use brain; make post; }

Joachim Neumann
Moderator
Moderator
 
Příspěvky: 26935
Založen: Jul 07, 2004
Bydliště: Neubiberg

Re: Angled roof ridge.

Odeslat Zaslal: 13.08.2017 19:28

#Der_Planer: You're thinking when drawing the roof outline around the walls, yes?

#Joachim: I see the function 2-04 Warped free roof surface. I tried to use it, but I don't understand how to use it, to do what I want. Maybe someone can give a step by step intro?
_________________
Sincerely Yours. M. Sc. E. Thorvald, Denmark
(Dietrichs version 7.03).

Thorvald
Tera Poster
Tera Poster
 
Příspěvky: 1063
Založen: Aug 16, 2006

Re: Angled roof ridge.

Odeslat Zaslal: 13.08.2017 21:28

Hi Thorvald,

I created 3 small building positions, to show you some roof calculations.
In pos 1 you find a rectangular building with 2 angeled edges. I made them bigger than required, the shortest length of the lines should be 2 cm. With longer lines it is easier to explain and see how it works.
Pos 1 works with the very normal roof calculation, which you probably use daily.

In pos 2, I made two roofs. I created some lines in dicam in order to have click points for roof calculation.

In pos 3 you find the same as in pos 2, only without roofs. This is for your exercise. Try to make the same roofs as I did.


The roofs in pos 2 are all made with funktion 2-03, the inclined roofs and the warped roofs.
To create the inclined roof, I turned the model to a non orthogonal view, in which I can find every 3d point (with no other point behind or too close to it). By clicking the points, the roof outlines will be drawn point by point.

At the back side, I created the same roof shape as at the front side, and moved 2 edge points to the original building edges (function 4-5-1). You can see, that the ground shape of the roof was not changed by this function, and after a recalculation, maybe the changes will be lost.
Please, try out to make the same changes with another function (2-01-4). The result will look the same, but it is no longer a temporary change.

To make the warped roof, I used the same dicam lines and click points, but on the bottom, I used the building edges at level ±0,00.
Click 4 points to create the warped outlines, and look at the status line, which explains the next step to do. After 1-3 tries, you will find out, how it works.
In my position, the front and the back roof have the same outlines, but if you put a rafter into both roofs, they will have different directions. The front one is defined to be parallel to the building, and the back rafter is rectangular to the ridge.

Please take as much time as you need, to learn roof calculation. If it lasts an hour or two, it's worth it.
_________________
Freundlich grüßt
Der_Planer

Der_Planer
Power-Experte
Power-Experte
 
Příspěvky: 10368
Založen: Aug 24, 2004
Bydliště: 51143 Köln

Re: Angled roof ridge.

Odeslat Zaslal: 14.08.2017 10:45

Hi.

I have tried a few things - but I am not sure what you are suggesting, will give me what I try to make. See attached.
_________________
Sincerely Yours. M. Sc. E. Thorvald, Denmark
(Dietrichs version 7.03).

Thorvald
Tera Poster
Tera Poster
 
Příspěvky: 1063
Založen: Aug 16, 2006

Re: Angled roof ridge.

Odeslat Zaslal: 14.08.2017 13:33

Hi.

I made an additional description and a new position.
All you have to prepare, is a building with click points. No matter, if they are points, end of lines or edges of beams. In my position, I used 2 floor points at the bottom and two end points of prepared lines.
The roof shape has only 4 points.

Please, look and try again.
_________________
Freundlich grüßt
Der_Planer

Der_Planer
Power-Experte
Power-Experte
 
Příspěvky: 10368
Založen: Aug 24, 2004
Bydliště: 51143 Köln

Re: Angled roof ridge.

Odeslat Zaslal: 14.08.2017 15:18

I am not sure if Thorvald wants a warped roof or not. We only know his tests but nothing about the base information.

- Is the building rectangular?
- Are the eaves parallel to the building?
_________________
Viele Grüße,
Joachim Neumann (Dietrich's AG)
Software für den Holzbau, Abbund, Holzrahmenbau, Blockbau, Ingenieurholzbau und für die Fertighausindustrie

if (ahnung == 0) { read "Tipps & Tricks"; use SEARCH; use Blog; } else { use brain; make post; }

Joachim Neumann
Moderator
Moderator
 
Příspěvky: 26935
Založen: Jul 07, 2004
Bydliště: Neubiberg

Re: Angled roof ridge.

Odeslat Zaslal: 14.08.2017 15:26

Ahhhaaaaaaa - hmmmm. Conlusion(?) It is not possible to do what I searched for, without curving the roof surface (warping) - am I right?? It isn't possible to do with a "flat" / straight roof surface?

So this what my brother is asking is not possible. At least not with CLT elements that we suppose to use and thus not without curving the roof, as my brother probably expect (and I also thought it is possible - but now I can see it is not possible).
_________________
Sincerely Yours. M. Sc. E. Thorvald, Denmark
(Dietrichs version 7.03).

Thorvald
Tera Poster
Tera Poster
 
Příspěvky: 1063
Založen: Aug 16, 2006

Re: Angled roof ridge.

Odeslat Zaslal: 14.08.2017 22:29

My dear friend, everything is possible with Dietrich's. Just have a closer look at my forum avatar. It was designed in dicam.

And, of course, your brother's problem can be solved with straight, flat roof calculation.
Parallel horizontal eaves, ridge with angle/pitch, no curved/warped roof, why should that not be possible?

Here you are...



... never give up Cool
_________________
Freundlich grüßt
Der_Planer

Der_Planer
Power-Experte
Power-Experte
 
Příspěvky: 10368
Založen: Aug 24, 2004
Bydliště: 51143 Köln

Re: Angled roof ridge.

Odeslat Zaslal: 15.08.2017 15:59

Hello Thorvald,

I suggest using only (3) points to create your initial roof plane using Graphic Roof creation. After that, create a fourth point on that plane and move the fourth point to position.

I have attached a video file to this post with a brief tutorial.

CptnLeif
Einsteiger
Einsteiger
 
Příspěvky: 8
Založen: Jul 24, 2015
Bydliště: Montana, United States

Re: Angled roof ridge.

Odeslat Zaslal: 21.08.2017 03:24

I wonder why I don't get e-mail notifications, when there are new answers. Maybe my registered e-mail is old, I have to look. But anyway, I've forgot to check if there were new answers.

Yes, Der_Planer, nearly everything is possible in Dietrichs, I know that. But this exact request is not as far as I can see. Your solution is close - but you still have to solve it by breaking the roof in two pieces. Because you need to fill the missing triangle.

#CptnLeif. I haven't yet seen how you try to solve it, but thanks for the answer
_________________
Sincerely Yours. M. Sc. E. Thorvald, Denmark
(Dietrichs version 7.03).

Thorvald
Tera Poster
Tera Poster
 
Příspěvky: 1063
Založen: Aug 16, 2006

Re: Angled roof ridge.

Odeslat Zaslal: 21.02.2018 09:08

Hello,
I have similar question about roof, attached .jpg. How I can to design curved roof in Dietrich's?

Giedrius
Dauerposter
Dauerposter
 
Příspěvky: 78
Založen: May 27, 2008

Curved Roof

Odeslat Zaslal: 21.02.2018 17:54

For the situation in this photo, I would draw the elliptical curve (outline) in Wall Design, then extrude the outlines in D-CAM (2-5). Be aware that Dietrich's will segment the extruded curved surface into a series of lines rather than one continuous curve.

CptnLeif
Einsteiger
Einsteiger
 
Příspěvky: 8
Založen: Jul 24, 2015
Bydliště: Montana, United States

Re: Angled roof ridge.

Odeslat Zaslal: 22.02.2018 16:05

It would be fine, if D-cad could produce elliptic lines, but it can't.
I would draw the outline shapes in an external 2d-cad, then import as dxf into DICAM, extrude, and work with it, not using the usual roof construction.

But, it would be possible as well, using roof design 2-05 (warped).
For me, it is easier to use DICAM, than forcing roof design to create those shapes.
_________________
Freundlich grüßt
Der_Planer

Der_Planer
Power-Experte
Power-Experte
 
Příspěvky: 10368
Založen: Aug 24, 2004
Bydliště: 51143 Köln
Zobrazit příspěvky z předchozích:   
Odpovědět na témaOdpovědět na téma Strana 1 z 1

Timber Design Modules

Přejdi na:  



Nemůžete odesílat nové téma do tohoto fóra
Nemůžete odpovídat na témata v tomto fóru
Nemůžete upravovat své příspěvky v tomto fóru
Nemůžete mazat své příspěvky v tomto fóru
Nemůžete hlasovat v tomto fóru
You cannot attach files in this forum
You cannot download files in this forum

Časy uváděny v GMT + 1 hodina